im sure thats backspacing, you would want a minimum of 7" on 9.5, so that would be 3.5" offset i believe, google up inches to millimeters and use a calculator.
to tuck, you are going to need around 42 to 45mm... anything less is cutting it too close, but with a smaller tire it would probably work against hitting the fenders (and you'll have to roll the fenders).