TwistedPhil
+1y
On some trucks, a skin makes more sense because of extra body lines that don't belong- 82-93 Chevy S10, Nissan Hardbody, etc.
On the Ranger (I assume from your profile that's the vehicle in question), it could work better for you to keep the tailgate and just shave the handle out of it. The Ranger 'gate has a slight curve in it from left to right, and if you replace it with a combo it will be flat across the back. It will still look good, but the original curve looks just a bit better in my opinion.
Of course, the combo will save you some bodywork in filling the gap between the tailgate and pan, but it's up to you whether that extra work is worth the gain.
Good luck either way!