gravity5
+1y
Butyl is typically used by the OEM's although it is black, silicone is not good as the acids in it can eat away at paint even if they do not touch as the fumes contain the acidid properties as well. Neutral cure silicone has no acids, but being silicone it will stick to everything and cannot be removed, also silicone and butyl do not bond together. I would use what was on there in the first place.