Cusser
+1y
The arrowed one is NOT an exhaust gasket (the one just above it is bottom of exhaust manifold to top of first catalytic converter gasket). I believe the arrowed gasket goes between the front part of the cylinder head and the main part of the cylinder head (I just did my B2200 engine rebuild in October). You'll be removing that front part to put in the camshaft seal that you show in the second-to-bottom opening in the head gasket in your photo.
Since you've got the timing belt off already, I'd replace the entire water pump. Because what if the leak is shaft seal leakage from the water pump weep hole and not from the gasket? You'd be tearing into it again. I did my water pump and new timing belt in May due to WP leakage out the weep hole. When I installed the new pistons, rings, connecting rod bearings, and rebuilt cylinder head, I didn't touch the 5-month-old WP.