Scoobysmak
+1y
Well I love my 03 Dodge. I have a tune on my truck so my digital readout reads higher than what I actually get. Empty I probably get around 22 mpg and when I put my enclosed trailer behind me I was getting around 14-15mpg (I weight of this setup is just under 22,000 lbs for everything). My "lie meter" as I have seen it called told me I was getting 24-25mpg empty but was pretty much on when I had a load. I have a 6 speed and love it when I see a hill, but alot of newer trucks have an exhaust brake so its not as much of a factor to own an automatic if it has one. If you look at an older dodge truck I would stay away from the auto because of the breakage factor but I hear with in the past couple years the auto is much better. I myself will always have a stick if I have an option.
Like others have said it more depends on what your going to use the truck for. I hear that a ford or chevy can beat a dodge off the line no problem but put the same load on them and run up a hill is another story (I would say a load would be atleast 6,000 lbs or none of the trucks would even feel it).
My first mistake was I got a 1994 Chevy with the 6.5l diesel, uh stay away unless you have alot of money to put into it. To give a comparison I hauled 7,000 lbs down I-24 from Nashville to Chattanooga. There is a pass called Monteagle, in the chevy I was floored doing 45 mph with the temp guage reading 230 degrees and climbing when I hit the top. Needless to say I knew at that point I was screwed for anything heavier. I ran that same route with 6,000 lbs in the dodge and ran up the hill at 70 mph on the cruise control and the temp never went over 205 degrees and normally sits around or just below 200. I am sure others have driven this before but for anyone that hasn't, heading south is the not so steep side of the mountain. If I was heading north I have no idea where the chevy would have gotten to but probably not the top. I only tell this story because I love that body style chevy and thought I could live with it, uh no, plan on a motor swap if you just got to have it.
From most of the things I have heard from people, best interior Ford, best motor Dodge, best transmission Chevy (my exception is any manual). I figured with the best engine and a good transmission I can live with a bad knob falling off the radio but I can't live with my butt stuck on the side of the road with an enclosed gooseneck trailer with two customs inside.
Overall its what you want to do with it, what makes you happy, and what you can live with or without.
I got my Dodge used three years ago with 178k on it and now it has 218k, the only problems I have had is the power steering pump died and my clutch took a crap about 2k miles ago. I figure 215k on a stock clutch towing at least part of its life is not too shabby.