Haha, that's funny. I have moments like that too. It's kinda flat. I think it looks alot like they normally would when they were new. Here's a pic of my truck, I'll let you judge how it looks for yourself. My bumper ends, and lower valance are both painted with it. The bumper ends were used so I had to paint them, and the valance was new but gray so I had to paint it so it would match.
I can take a closer up picture of the pieces this weekend if you want me to.