emjay
+1y
My guess here is that the air/fuel mixture isn't burining in one of the cylinders, and the fuel that is coming out is because of such. Pics would help here. First thing that I would check is to see if all the spark plug wires are connected. Also, check the condition of the spark plugs, let us know if one looks any different than the other.
More advance testing you could do, perform a compression check on your vehicle, both dry and wet. Fuel lines don't typically run past the exhaust side on our trucks so I doubt that there is any fuel leakage from any lines landing on your exhaust manifold.
We do need more information though, is it a 5 spd or an automatic?