kam
+1y
My understanding of chemistry (which is... somewhat decent) tells me that the reason Phosphoric acid works better is not PkA but because of the size of the molecules themselves.
That is: CH3COOH is less awesome than H3PO4 (in the sense that when the lil' buggers get to bouncing around and doing science stuff, the smaller, the better)
But yeah. Phosphoric isn't as easy to get as vinegar, though its not that hard to find. Hardware and paint supply stores will have it by various names, so will Lowes and Home Depot.
For example @ HomeDepot, look for "Behr Concrete Rust Stain Remover"
at other places it might just be called "Metal Prep Solution" etc etc.
Wouldn't use the jelly kind. "Naval Jelly" has other stuff in it that will make the flush harder.
By the way. Phosphoric Acid IS sewer-safe.
But yeah. Vinegar should work reasonably well, at least well enough to get flow through the heater core again, restoring most functionality. The difference is that Vinegar solutions often will get rid of the "Big chunks" and most of the blockage, but the scale that is caked on the walls of the tubes (which WILL act much as an insulating medium) is much harder to dissolve away, and very hard to tell if its around. Additionally, the little patches of scale that might linger around cause another problem...
Scale is like cholesterol. Once you get a little, more comes. Its a surface-based reaction after all. A pipe with no scale won't clog up very fast. A pipe with 1% blockage will begin to scale up at the surface. Then, bam! All heck breaks loose. Scale builds up on scale, which begins to clog up the pipe. When the pipe gets clogged, flow slows down, which lets more scale build up ontop of scale... and when it is all over, heart attack.
So, the more clean you can get the pipes inside the heater core, the longer it will last, and the more heating it will do.
For all the effort that could be put into this to restore the heater core, I'd spend the extra few dollars, and the little bit of hardware-store hopping to make the inside of the core good as new. That way, you won't need to worry about this... for oh, another 20 years?
No offense, mister Cusser. Believe me. If $1.35/gallon vinegar worked as well as phosphoric acid, I would have been flushing gallons of that through copper pipes. The truth is though, that PkA isn't everything, and the pros use Phosphoric for good reasons.
Though, in a pinch, vinegar will work. Maybe try and use a bendy brush (like the kind they use to scrub trumpets and such out) through the core halfway through the flush to try and break up more of that nasty scale. (The glassy kind is the WORST.) Stay vigilant.
(This is why I use cheap walmart-bought spring water in my coolant system instead of tap. Funny thing, that. Its the only bottled water I buy)